L4M4 Ethical and Responsible Sourcing Question and Answers

Public sector sourcing prioritises maintaining service levels within budget constraints and often mandates competitive tendering to promote transparency and fairness. These principles align with ethical sourcing practices, ensuring responsible expenditure and fair competition among suppliers.

Explanation

the correct answer is 'marketplace competition'.

Ethical practice is about prohibiting corrupt and unfair practice, rather than issues of supply and demand. Although being in a cartel is 'unethical behavior' this option doesn't fully answer the question which talks about limiting supply- this is related to marketplace competition.

Explanation

Incoterms can replace lengthy contract clauses as they replace the need for contracts to detail which party is responsible for organising transport, paying duties, having the insurance etc.

Incoterms is an odd one for exam topics- some students say it was a huge part of their exam and there were many questions on this. Others said there were just one or two. Questions get randomly assigned from the bank so it's completely random how many you'll get on this topic.

Incorporating standards within specifications provides clear guidelines for suppliers, reducing ambiguity and helping ensure consistency in quality and performance. This aligns with ethical and responsible sourcing practices by promoting transparency and setting consistent expectations for suppliers.

Explanation

The correct answer is 'no - added value may change from one company to another'.

Added value is very subjective. What one person thinks is excellent added value, another may not rate highly. For example one buyer may consider a supplier having good brand reputation as added value, but another might not care.

The other no answer is incorrect because added value can be tangible or intangible. Tangible means you can touch and see it and intangible means you can't.

Explanation

the correct answer is 'no- the public sector can choose not to publish information if it is not deemed to be in the public interest'.

They use something called the 'public interest test' to determine if the information should be re-leased or not. For example they may not respond to a request asking how many bullets the UK Army has in storage, as that would be detrimental to national security interests.

Responses to requests are made within 21 days, not 28.

Incoterms are grouped as E (Ex Works), F (Free Carrier), C (Carriage Paid To), and D (Delivered Duty Paid), reflecting various stages of responsibility transfer between buyer and seller. Understanding Incoterms is critical for responsible sourcing, as it clarifies logistics and cost responsibilities.

Conducting periodic audits by third-party specialists is a reliable way to monitor compliance with ethical standards, as these audits provide an objective assessment. This aligns with ethical sourcing practices, as it promotes accountability and ensures continuous adherence to agreed-upon standards.

Explanation

Primary data includes trade fairs and exhibits, and phone calls to current suppliers. The others are examples of secondary data.

Remember primary= you do it yourself, Secondary = someone else did it.

Explanation

EXW- exworks is a suitable incoterm for transporting goods both by rail and boat. It can be used regardless of the mode of transport. The other three are for transport over water. P. 143 Shipping Incoterms: the Complete Guide - Guided Imports

Some students report a lot of questions on Incoterms in the exam, some say they only had 1. Best bet is to learn them if you possibly can.

Explanation

The lowest risk to the buyer is 'delivered duty paid'. This is because the supplier does all the work transporting the items to the buyer's premises. Incoterms_2020_chart | Intersped

Explanation

Open account (aka credit account) is most beneficial to the buyer. The supplier delivers the goods then the buyer pays.

Cash in advance is most beneficial to the supplier. The buyer pays for the item before receiving it.

This is a known exam topic.

Liquidity ratios, such as the current and quick ratios, evaluate a company's ability to meet short-term liabilities with current assets. This metric is crucial for assessing a supplier’s financial stability, ensuring continuity and reliability in the supply chain, which aligns with ethical and responsible sourcing principles.

A current ratio below 1 suggests that the supplier may not have sufficient current assets to cover short-term liabilities, which could pose a risk to the buyer. Assessing financial stability aligns with responsible sourcing practices, as it ensures suppliers can fulfill contracts without disruption.

Incoterms clarify responsibilities between buyers and sellers, reducing certain risks but not eliminating them entirely. Responsible sourcing requires recognising that Incoterms are only part of risk management in international trade, and other factors, such as supplier reliability and quality, must be considered.

An Invitation to Tender (ITT) is typically used for complex, high-value procurements where the quality and specific features of the goods or services are of paramount importance. This approach ensures that ethical and responsible sourcing criteria are met, aligning with best practices in procuring specialised goods or services.

Unscheduled audits can provide an unbiased view of supplier practices and help identify compliance issues that might be hidden during scheduled audits. This approach supports responsible sourcing by ensuring accurate assessments of ethical and quality standards.

Explanation

The three pillars of sustainability are profit, people and planet. This may also be referred to as social, economic and environmental.

Professional magazines, economic indices, and supplier websites provide secondary data that can be useful in understanding market trends and supplier performance. Responsible sourcing often relies on a mix of primary and secondary data sources to make informed decisions about supplier selection.

Explanation

total life-cycle costs include; acquisition costs, maintenance and training.

Added value and functional fit are quality criteria that should also be evaluated when selecting a supplier, but do not fall under total life-cycle costs.

Note: total life cycle costs and whole life asset management are the same thing. You may see both terms used in the exam. I think CIPS is moving more towards Whole Life Asset Management now as the preferred vocabulary but they're the same thing.

Explanation

cash in advance is the most beneficial to a supplier.

Open account /credit account is the most beneficial to the buyer. Learn this as it's a known exam topic.

A full competitive tendering process ensures fairness by treating all suppliers equally, allowing them to compete on a level playing field. This aligns with ethical sourcing principles, especially in the public sector, where transparency and equal opportunity are paramount.

Explanation

If tenders are received by electronic submission exclusively, the buyer can reduce the timescale. On average the time for a standard tender submission can be reduced by 5 days if bids are submitted electronically.

*Note* this is based off current PCR Regs 2015 which are being superseded in October 2024 by new legislation. We currently don't know what the new regs will say on this. If it's different, my best guess is CIPS will remove any question about it from their exam- because the study guide would be wrong and that would lead to complaints.

Explanation

New organisations or those with no loans/ credit cards may have low credit scores. This is simply because they do not have enough financial history to make their scores good. That means banks au-tomatically class them as higher risk, because they simply don't know that they're trustworthy yet.

Explanation

A credit rating generates a score which reflects 'the level of risk an organisation poses when dealing with other businesses'. It's saying how risky it is to loan them money or do business with them by looking at how good they are at paying people. So a high credit rating will say they're good at paying back their loans and paying their suppliers on time. A poor credit rating will say they often miss payments or pay late.

A credit rating will not tell you how much money they have, or details on their prices. Credit scores looks at purely financial data so wouldn't help you analyse whether their business practices are ethical or not.

Explanation

The correct answer is bribery, corruption and the environment.

ESG stands for environmental and social governance. It's the new buzzword for CIPS and is basically everything to do with ethical procurement- so areas such as bribery and corruption are included as well as the environment.

Option 4 is incorrect as economic doesn't come into it.

Explanation

You should investigate automatically low tenders by clarifying the bid with the supplier. It could be they have misunderstood the requirement. Or the bid could be genuine and they can really provide best value for money. But without enquiring, you just don't know.

Explanation

This is sole sourcing as there is only one supplier in the marketplace.

Be careful not to confuse single sourcing and sole sourcing. Single sourcing is when a buyer chooses to work with only one supplier (usually to achieve economies of scale), sole sourcing, on the other hand, is when the buyer doesn't have a choice- they work with one supplier because there is only one supplier in the market.

Types of sourcing is a key concept for this exam.

Explanation

The correct answer is 'no- quoting in the supplier's currency increases the risk for the buyer'. This questions comes up in a variety of formats in the exam. Remember; if the price is in your own currency (most examples in the exam are given in £) there is less risk than if the prices are quoted in a foreign currency. This is because exchange rates fluctuate; if the price is in £ you always know what you're paying, if it's in another currency the price can change daily depending on if the exchange rate compared to £ has gone up or down.

Explanation

ILO = the International Labour Organisation.

ISO is the International Standardisation Organisation- they also come up in this exam.

Fair Trade is about paying suppliers properly.

WWF is the World Wildlife Foundation, or if you watched wrestling in the 90s, the original WWE. You do not need to know about wildlife or wrestling for this exam.

Explanation

An oligopoly. Perfect competition is a situation in a marketplace where there is plenty of competition. A monopoly or monopolistic competition would have 'imperfect competition'

Explanation

Open tenders should be used when the buyer expects there to be little interest / fewer bids. The opportunity is advertised widely allowing any supplier that wishes to submit a bid the opportunity.

The other options limit the number of suppliers and Ji Yuan doesn't want to do that, because he risks getting no interest and no supplier.

P.23

Explanation

An ITT would include details on the awarding body (usually a brief overview of the buyer), the deadline (bids must be received by a certain date) and qualifications required (such as ISO requirements or competency certificates of staff members if it's a service contract). You wouldn't find pricing schedules in an ITT (this would be provided by the supplier in response to the ITT), nor would you find risk assessments (a supplier might be asked to provide one as part of the quality assessment of the tender though).

Invitation To Tender Simply Explained I Thornton & Lowe (thorntonandlowe.com)

Explanation

The correct answers are 'it is easy to drive down costs' (as you can pit the suppliers against each other) and 'low risk of failure to supply' (if one supplier can't provide what you need, the other supplier might be able to).

Economies of scale and supplier loyalty are advantages of single-sourcing.

There is a risk of failure to supply is a risk associated with single sourcing.

There's a useful table of advantages and disadvantages of single / multi sourcing on p.22. Types of sourcing is a key topic for the exam.

Compliance with fair trade standards demonstrates the supplier's commitment to social responsibility, including fair wages and ethical working conditions. This aligns with responsible sourcing practices, ensuring that suppliers maintain ethical labor standards, as advocated in the principles of ethical sourcing.

Employee working conditions, a code of ethics, and a carbon emissions policy are all indicative of a supplier's commitment to ESG standards. Assessing these factors aligns with responsible sourcing practices, which prioritize sustainability and ethical considerations.

Explanation

In a 'Credit Account' payment mechanism- the supplier receives payment after the goods are delivered, in line with agreed payment terms (which may be 30 days or something like that).

Explanation

A Category spend is high value and strategic suppliers. C category is low value, high volume of spend aka tail spend. The bits in the middle are B category.

For example when you have a baby you have to buy lots of stuff for it. Your A spend is the big, important and expensive purchases like the pram, cot, carseat. You spend a lot of time in this category because they're important purchases you want to get right. The Tail Spend / C are all thelittle bits like nappies, baby shampoo, sippy cups. The B category are the bits in between - the purchases are kinda important but aren't as strategic or important as A category. Toys may fall into this category.

Explanation

This is accommodating: the supplier puts the buyer's interest above his own.

This is from the Thomas Killman model of conflict resolution. There are 5 strategies; competitive, collaborative, avoiding, accommodating and compromising. In the study guide it doesn't mention the name of the model but you do need to know the 5 strategies. The model comes up a lot in other modules so is a good one to learn. Particularly L5M1 which is about management theory.

Explanation

The correct answer is 'yes - these can be completed without warning which would give Ali an accurate picture of the supplier's operations'. The other options are incorrect:

1) you can do many types of audit- financial, ethical, Health and Safety etc

2) asking a supplier about their ethical practices isn't likely going to get you accurate information. They'll just tell you what they think you want to hear

3) audits are great- but they don't ALWAYS uncover issues. Always is the key word in that sentence which makes it incorrect.

Response times should be tailored to the complexity of the tender. Responsible sourcing encourages flexibility in setting realistic timelines that allow suppliers adequate time to prepare, supporting efficient and effective sourcing without unnecessary delays.

The Triple Bottom Line framework evaluates an organisation's impact on social, environmental, and economic factors. Financial and environmental performance are critical components, along with social metrics, aligning with responsible sourcing goals to promote sustainability and ethical practices.

The bill of lading serves as both a receipt of goods and a document of title, which means it confirms the contract of carriage and can transfer ownership. Responsible sourcing in international trade requires precise documentation, which is why the bill of lading is critical in verifying both carriage and title.

The acid test (quick ratio) is an effective measure of a supplier's ability to meet short-term liabilities, providing insights into financial stability. This aligns with responsible sourcing by ensuring the supplier is financially capable of fulfilling a strategic contract.

Explanation

cost and freight is specific to transport over water. The others relate to all types of transportation. Incoterms_2020_chart | Intersped

Some students report a lot of questions on Incoterms in the exam, some say they only had 1. It real-ly is luck of the draw.

Advertising in a local newspaper for a specialized requirement can lead to irrelevant bids, delaying the process. Efficient sourcing practices recommend targeted advertising to reach qualified suppliers, ensuring timely responses and reducing assessment time, especially for urgent needs.

The withholding of passports is a potential indication of modern slavery, and the offer of a discount to avoid reporting this is a form of bribery. Reporting these ethical concerns aligns with responsiblesourcing practices and is critical for maintaining a supply chain free from human rights abuses.

Explanation

EBITDA stands for 'earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization'. This is a profitability ratio and would show how profitable a business is.

EBITDA: Definition, Calculation Formulas, History, and Criticisms (investopedia.com)

Explanation

tactical is the correct answer; items that are short-term or low value are considered tactical.

Strategic sourcing is long term and high value.

Outsourcing is moving a key business function to an external company.

Insourcing is bringing a previously outsourced part of the company back in-house.

Adopting ISO environmental standards aligns procurement practices with sustainability goals and helps reduce environmental and social impacts. Although implementing ISO standards may require initial adjustments, they foster long-term benefits by promoting responsible and ethical sourcing practices across the supply chain.

Payment history and financial stress scores provide insights into a supplier’s financial health and stability. This information is crucial for procurement professionals in assessing whether a supplier can fulfill long-term commitments, supporting responsible sourcing by mitigating financial risks.